Is MSK Ultrasound Too User Dependent? Why Training Beats the Objection

Is MSK ultrasound too operator dependent to trust? Ryan Martin and Colin Rigney take on the most common objection and explain why the answer is a system, reps and hands-on training.

"It's so user dependent." It is the objection Ryan Martin and Colin Rigney hear more than any other about bringing MSK ultrasound into practice. In this episode they take it head on. X-rays are position dependent, MRI is reader dependent, surgery has its errors too, and every one of them is learned as a system. Ultrasound is no different: a systematic scan, enough reps with feedback, and a mentor beside you. They share how an ER physician got comfortable with a technical procedure in about 50 reps, how a resident went from no ultrasound at all in February to ultrasound guided PRP and bone marrow procedures a few months later, and why you cannot learn a hands-on skill from YouTube alone.
What this episode covers:
  • Why user dependence is the objection that comes up most about MSK ultrasound
  • Operator dependence in every modality: x-ray positioning, MRI reading, surgery
  • Ultrasound as a system: shining a flashlight under the skin and working your checkpoints
  • Plays are made to be broken, once you know the playbook
  • Not operator dependent, system dependent
  • How many reps it really takes: 50 and a backboard to learn from
  • The road to mastery goes through incompetency
  • From no ultrasound in February to ultrasound guided PRP and bone marrow procedures months later
  • Why you can't learn a hands-on skill from YouTube, and why accountability matters
  • The "I don't want to go back to school" mountain
  • Voices from the 2025 AMSKU Annual Global Summit
Links mentioned in this episode:
New episodes every Tuesday. Watch on YouTube, or listen on Spotify and Apple Podcasts.
Chapters:
0:00 This week on From Probe to Practice
0:25 From Probe to Practice
0:38 The objection: MSK ultrasound is too user dependent
1:45 MRI is the gold standard, and still reader dependent
2:41 A flashlight under the skin: ultrasound as a system
3:24 A handheld skill still has a system
4:08 "It's so user dependent." There's training for that
5:15 Errors in MRI, CT scans and surgery too
6:38 Plays are made to be broken
7:18 Not operator dependent, system dependent
7:38 Talking a clinician through the objection
8:04 50 reps: how an ER physician learned a technical procedure
9:02 15 orthopedic surgeons in one week
9:56 The road to mastery goes through incompetency
10:07 February to June: a resident's first guided procedures
11:25 Learning MSK ultrasound without a fellowship
12:29 A hundred books on riding a bicycle
13:14 Accountability and a residency style program
14:55 Why we welcome the objections
16:00 The mountain: "I don't want to go back to school"
16:39 Raising the standard at the point of care
17:34 Coming up: more objections, and a live Q&A
18:23 Voices from the 2025 AMSKU Annual Global Summit